diff --git a/src/main/kotlin/xyz/alexcrea/cuanvil/util/AnvilLoreEditUtil.kt b/src/main/kotlin/xyz/alexcrea/cuanvil/util/AnvilLoreEditUtil.kt
index e3b052a..25256a1 100644
--- a/src/main/kotlin/xyz/alexcrea/cuanvil/util/AnvilLoreEditUtil.kt
+++ b/src/main/kotlin/xyz/alexcrea/cuanvil/util/AnvilLoreEditUtil.kt
@@ -192,17 +192,24 @@ object AnvilLoreEditUtil {
         val line = if (removeEnd) lore.removeAt(lore.size - 1)
         else lore.removeAt(0)
 
-        meta.lore = if (lore.isEmpty()) null else lore
+        meta.lore = null
         result.itemMeta = meta
 
+        // Update lore but make sure custom lore is put last
+        DependencyManager.updateLore(result)
+
+        val finalLore = ArrayList<String>()
+        finalLore.addAll(meta.lore!!)
+        finalLore.addAll(lore)
+
+        meta.lore = lore
+        if (result == first) return null
+
         // Get color cost to uncolor this line
         val tempList = ArrayList<String>(1)
         tempList.add(line)
         val uncolorCost = uncolorLines(player, tempList, LoreEditType.REMOVE_PAPER)
 
-        DependencyManager.updateLore(result)
-        if (result == first) return null
-
         // Handle other xp
         xpCost.addAndGet(uncolorCost)
         xpCost.addAndGet(baseEditLoreXpCost(first, result, LoreEditType.REMOVE_PAPER))